| 2003 | Elizabeth Ryder (Cumberland) | Middlebury College |
| 2004 | Alicia Ramsdell (Wells) | Flager College |
| Elizabeth Ryder (Cumberland) | Middlebury | |
| Shannon Mitchell (Durham) | Catawba College | |
| 2006 | Megan Angis | Sienna College |
| Abigail DiBiase | Suffolk University | |
| Rebecca Dyer | University of Maine, Orono | |
| Ashley Wing | University of Maine, Orono | |
| 2007 | Kristina Lawson | University of Southern Maine |
| Kristin Orr | St. Anslem College | |
| Emily Bouchard | University of Southern Maine | |
| Kathy Murphy | Northeastern University | |
| Aimie Chiasson | University of Maine, Orono | |
| Audrey Roy | Gordon College | |
| 2008 | Aimie Chiasson | University of Maine, Orono |
| 2009 | Amie Chaisson | University of Maine, Orono |
| Lisa Rogers | University of Vermont | |
| Kate Merrill | Mount Holyoke | |
| Alexa Rancourt | Furman University | |
| 2010 | Amie Chaisson | University of Maine, Orono |
| Kate Merrill | Mount Holyoke | |
| Kerri Grant | University of New England, Biddeford | |
| Linnea Tilberg | Rennsselaier Polytechnic Institute | |